Many people struggle to balance muscle growth with fat control, especially those who dislike the aggressive cycles of bulking and cutting. Maingaining offers a middle-ground approach: building muscle steadily while minimizing fat gain. This method, backed by recent research, is a sustainable alternative to extreme diet shifts, appealing to everyday exercisers who want lean gains without obsessive calorie counting.
How Maingaining Works: A Subtle Surplus
Maingaining centers on a slight calorie surplus – roughly 5% above maintenance – combined with consistent strength training and prioritized protein intake. A recent study in Sports Medicine-Open showed that a 5% surplus was just as effective for muscle strength as a 15% surplus, without the excess weight gain. The key is consistency, not extremes. Your body doesn’t need massive calorie spikes to build muscle; a small, steady increase is often enough.
This contrasts sharply with traditional bulking, where people intentionally eat large surpluses (up to 20%) knowing they’ll gain fat alongside muscle. Maingaining avoids this volatility, making it ideal for those who prefer gradual progress over drastic fluctuations.
Is Maingaining Right for Women?
While historically geared toward bodybuilders, maingaining is increasingly recognized as effective for women who strength train. The method’s focus on consistency helps avoid the pitfalls of yo-yo dieting. Individual results vary, but women with a solid training routine (at least three sessions weekly, hitting each muscle group twice) tend to see the most success.
However, the effectiveness depends on how diligently you track calories and macros. The more consistent you are, the better your body responds.
Getting Started: A 3-Step Plan
-
Calculate Maintenance Calories: Use an online tool (like the NIH Body Weight Planner) to determine how many calories you need to maintain your current weight. Then, add a 5% surplus. For a 150-pound person eating 2,000 calories, that’s just 100 extra calories – barely more than a spoonful of peanut butter.
-
Prioritize Protein: Aim for 0.8 to 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight. For our example, that’s 120–150 grams daily. Use apps like MyFitnessPal or Lose It! to track intake and ensure you’re hitting your target. Any additional calories can come from carbs or fats.
-
Train Strategically: Consistent strength training is non-negotiable. Focus on progressive overload (gradually increasing weight, reps, or intensity) and full-body workouts hitting each muscle group twice weekly. Remember: eating extra without training leads to fat storage, not muscle growth. Prioritize compound movements like squats, deadlifts, and push-ups, along with accessory exercises.
Manage Expectations: Slow Progress, Real Results
Maingaining produces slower muscle growth than bulking but avoids the fat gain. It’s about playing the long game for sustainable progress. Celebrate small wins – feeling stronger or noticing more definition – rather than chasing rapid transformations.
This approach suits those who prefer avoiding fat gain altogether or dislike the cyclical nature of bulking and cutting. However, experienced lifters may need a larger surplus to see changes, and genetics play a role in how responsive your body is.
Ultimately, maingaining offers a realistic path to building muscle without the extremes. If you value consistency over rapid gains, this method may be the ideal fit. Consider consulting a dietitian or trainer for personalized guidance. Remember: slow progress is still progress, and consistency remains key.
